The Books I Keep Rereading (Even When I Tell Myself Not To)

You can learn a surprising amount about someone by noticing what they keep returning to—especially when it comes to books. That’s why putting together this list made me feel oddly exposed. Vulnerable, even. So go easy on me, okay?

This isn’t a “Top 10 Books of All Time” list. It’s not a “Best Writing Ever” roundup either. These aren’t necessarily the most intellectual, life-altering, or critically acclaimed books I’ve read.

These are simply the stories I keep coming back to—the ones that feel like home when the world gets too loud.

They may not have changed my life, but they absolutely changed the way I see it.

What Makes These Books Special to Me?

• They feel like old friends.

• They comfort me in times of chaos.

• They’re the kind of books that look worn out because I can’t help revisiting them.

• They’re not perfect—but they’re perfect for me.

Here’s my deeply personal reread list:

1. Harry Potter Series (Books 1–7) by J.K. Rowling

“Hogwarts will always be there to welcome you home.”

Even after two decades, nothing beats the magic of the Wizarding World. I never wore round glasses or waited for an owl to drop by, but I believed in it all the same.

Why I Keep Coming Back:

• Heartfelt friendships and fierce loyalty

• Comforting innocence despite dark themes

• A powerful message: Love conquers all

• Best slow-burn mysteries I’ve ever read

2. The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky

Dostoevsky is not easy reading. But wow, is he worth it. His writing doesn’t just peel back a character’s mind—it digs right into their soul.

Why This Book Stays With Me:

• Knyaz Myshkin: a hero of kindness in a world that doesn’t know what to do with it

• A rare novel that explores pure human decency

• Soulful, philosophical, and heartbreakingly beautiful

3. Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë

Not a fan of certain romance tropes, yet Jane Eyre won me over completely. This one is all about atmosphere and quiet strength.

What Draws Me In:

• Protagonists who look ordinary but feel extraordinary

• Strong moral consequences and emotional depth

• Beautifully gothic setting

4. Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen

Sometimes, I read a few poorly written books and need something to reset my literary taste buds. That’s when I reach for Austen.

This Book Has:

• Razor-sharp wit and elegant prose

• Romantic tension that’s still top-tier centuries later

• Endearing characters and timeless themes

5. The Wall of Winnipeg and Me by Mariana Zapata

Mariana Zapata masters the slow-burn like no one else. And I mean slow. But it’s so worth it.

Why I Reread It Constantly:

• Realistic emotional build-up

• No clichés or instant chemistry—just genuine connection

• Comforting and grounding when life gets messy

6. Can You Keep a Secret? by Sophie Kinsella

The only chick-lit on this list—and it earned its place. This one’s hilarious, heartfelt, and just the right amount of romantic.

Why It’s Not Just Fluff:

• Sharp dialogue and memorable characters

• Story of self-acceptance and vulnerability

• Genuinely laugh-out-loud funny moments

7. The Host by Stephenie Meyer

Let’s be honest—I didn’t expect to like this one. But it totally caught me off guard.

Why I Enjoy It (Again and Again):

• Original premise and surprisingly strong characters

• Easier to digest than most sci-fi

• Emotionally immersive despite a few awkward moments 🙂

8. Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll

This book followed me from childhood into adulthood—and somehow, it always means something new.

Why I Treasure It:

• Surreal yet full of hidden truths

• Magical writing that bends reality

• A perfect blend of chaos and wisdom

9. Thoughtless by S.C. Stephens

Okay. Hear me out. This one’s a rollercoaster. I’ve yelled at the pages. I’ve cried. I’ve sworn I wouldn’t pick it up again—and then did anyway.

Why It Keeps Haunting Me:

• Raw emotion and emotional chaos

• Love triangle done intensely

• Infuriating, heartbreaking, and still unforgettable

Final Thoughts

These books might not be perfect on paper. But to me? They’re like a cozy sweater I refuse to throw away, no matter how many holes it has. They’re warm. Familiar. Honest.

They remind me that stories don’t have to be flawless to feel just right.

FAQs

1. Why do people reread books instead of picking new ones?

Rereading can offer comfort, familiarity, and a deeper appreciation for stories and characters you already love. It’s like catching up with an old friend.

2. What does your favorite reread say about you?

Often, the books you return to reflect your values, emotional needs, or even the kind of world you wish to live in. They resonate with your core.

3. Is it okay to love a “badly written” book?

Absolutely. Reading is personal. What moves you doesn’t have to impress critics or win awards—it just has to connect.

4. How do I build my own “comfort bookshelf”?

Start with books that have made you feel seen, safe, or inspired. If you’ve already reread something once, that’s a good sign it belongs.

Click here to learn more