The UK’s Move to Ban No-Fault Evictions: A Closer Look

The UK government is on the brink of implementing a significant change: banning “no-fault” evictions in England, a reform that aims to provide greater security for renters. Though this decision was announced post-election and highlighted in the King’s Speech, it has taken years to reach this point. Here, we explore the implications of this reform, the potential impact on tenants and landlords, and the additional issues facing renters.

What is a No-Fault Eviction?

A no-fault eviction, enabled by Section 21 of the Housing Act 1988, allows landlords to evict tenants without giving a reason, provided they offer a minimum two-month notice. This practice has been widely criticized for leaving tenants vulnerable and without security.

Background: Previous Promises and Delays

• 2019 Conservative Manifesto: Initial commitment by Prime Minister Boris Johnson.
• Delays: Concerns over an overloaded court system and slow processing times stalled reform.
• Recent Compromise: In 2024, just before the general election, a compromise required the lord chancellor to confirm the court system’s readiness before the law could take effect—potentially leading to further delays.

Why Abolish No-Fault Evictions?

The proposed change aims to bring security to approximately 11 million private renters in England. Key goals include:

• Increased Housing Stability: Tenants can feel secure in their homes without fear of unexpected eviction.
• Improved Housing Quality: Tenants may feel more confident raising concerns about disrepair and poor landlord practices without fearing retaliation.

However, as promising as it sounds, eliminating no-fault evictions may have a range of effects on the private rental market.

Impact on Tenants: Stability with Challenges

Positive Effects

• Reduced Retaliatory Evictions: Tenants can report unsafe conditions without fear of reprisal.
• Greater Confidence in Reporting Issues: Tenants will likely raise issues about repairs and dampings more often, improving housing standards.

Challenges Ahead

1. Evictions on Legal Grounds
   Tenants evicted on grounds like rent arrears, property damage, or nuisance may face severe challenges:

   Legal Grounds for Eviction	Impact on Tenants
   Rent Arrears	Can lead to intentional homelessness classification.
   Property Damage/Nuisance	Likely ineligible for social housing.

   This classification may relieve pressure on local councils to provide temporary housing but could leave low-income renters vulnerable, with fewer options for social housing.

2. Tenant vs. Licensee Status In the absence of Section 21, landlords might attempt to:
   • Classify Tenants as Licensees: Reducing tenants’ rights by downgrading them to “licensees,” who have fewer legal protections.
   • Claim Resident Landlord Status: Presenting tenants as “lodgers” to bypass tenant protections.
3. Legal Representation Limitations
   Unlike previous decades, current legal aid options are sparse, leaving tenants with limited support. Facing legal proceedings without proper representation can be daunting, especially for low-income tenants.

Landlord Concerns and Market Impact

Some landlords argue that the elimination of no-fault evictions could decrease rental supply, as they may feel compelled to exit the market under heightened regulations. However:

• Research Indicates Minimal Impact: Past regulatory changes haven’t triggered large-scale landlord exits.
• Main Drivers: Studies show that tax changes and rising borrowing costs have a more substantial impact on landlords than regulatory shifts.

Case Study: Scotland

Scotland’s experience with banning no-fault evictions under the Private Housing (Tenancies) (Scotland) Act 2016 suggests that increased regulation doesn’t necessarily lead to landlords leaving the market.

Issues Beyond No-Fault Evictions

Even with the ban on no-fault evictions, other challenges persist for renters:

1. Rental Affordability
   Rising rent prices, driven by high demand and limited supply, remain a significant hurdle.
   • The government has promised to enable tenants to challenge rent increases and prevent bidding wars, but there’s no formal rent cap.
   • With high rental costs, renters struggling with affordability are at higher risk of eviction due to arrears, which can further intensify the call for rent control.
2. Illegal Evictions and Harassment
   Without clear reform of outdated eviction laws, frustrated landlords might resort to illegal evictions or harassment to expedite the process. Strengthening protections against illegal evictions could help address this concern.

What Does This Mean for the Future of Renting in the UK?

The abolition of no-fault evictions is a step toward providing security for renters. Yet, without addressing affordability and legal protections, it may only scratch the surface of a complex housing issue. As rental costs rise and calls for rent controls grow, housing reform may need to encompass broader changes to address the core issues affecting renters across the UK.

Click here to learn more